Book #62: Antonin Scalia, A Matter of Interpretation

A Matter of Interpretation collects together Scalia’s Tanner Lecture and comment essays by Laurence Tribe, Gordon Wood, Ronald Dworkin, and Mary Ann Glendon.  Scalia’s lecture is quite interesting, and covers both statutory and constitutional interpretation.  As  several commenters noted, Scalia’s favored methods for statutory interpretation seem quite sensible and non-controversial; I would tend to agree, for example, that legislative intent and history is largely irrelevant to what was actually enacted.  It is a different, and structural, issue if the content of enacted legislation is unknown to, or does not reflect, the intent of legislators.  But it is not an issue of interpretation.

Of course, most people reading the book come for the constitutional issues, like myself.  Here, I find myself on changing ground.  Insofar as "originalism" of any stripe involves reconstruction of past intents or "public meanings," we have an empirical problem not unlike that faced by archaeologists "reconstructing" past cultural practices.  Such interpretations are unfalsifiable almost by definition, and thus strict "originalists" face the same problem they accuse the "living constitution" folks of having:  ultimately both methods produce arguments that are made in the present by actors who vary widely in their motives, allegiences, and ideas of permissible judicial action.  To the extent that originalists rely only upon "public meaning" (the current method in vogue within originalist circles), and use only textual sources for public meaning (i.e., dictionaries, publicly available writings), the interpretive method may verge upon textualism — which is ultimately the position that Scalia describes as his own. 

Mary Ann Glendon does an excellent job in her comment describing how civil-law systems in Europe have retreated from strict textualism over the last generation, and explores their reasoning.  Ultimately, she provides an excellent rationale for a synthetic approach to constitutional interpretation, which combines textual structural analysis (of the kind that Amar’s recent book does so brilliantly for the American case) with a formalist common-law approach similiar to that common in Germany’s constitutional court.  I need to think a bit more on this, and review how this relates to both Amar’s liberal textualism and Larry Solum’s "neo-formalist" approach, but it does seem to avoid the unacknowledged unfalsifiability of originalism while not falling into the tarpit of "realist" approaches to liberal "living" constitutionalism. 

Comments

16 Comments so far. Comments are closed.
  1. Greenhouse Gases Continue to Rise (AP)

    widely blamed for raising the planets temperature are still building up in the

  2. Paris Hilton’s Monkey, Baby Luv, Confiscated

    baby love, my baby love I need you, oh how I need you. But all you do is treat me bad. Break my heart and leave me sad. Tell me, what did I do wrong.

  3. Spy’s Death Won’t Help Northern Ireland Relations, Irish Pre

    Fein official who had admitted spying for the British will make a new power-sharing deal in Northern Ireland more difficult, Irish Prime Minister Bertie

  4. “Why coffee is just what a premature baby needs”

    of a well conducted trial. As the trial is ongoing, the long-term results for the effects of caffeine treatment are not yet available.

  5. Autism diagnosis remains through early childhood

    not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS) and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) — later have their diagnoses changed to autism.

  6. Suns See Brighter Moments Ahead

    5 of the Western Conference finals. Stoudemire looked antsy. He talked defiantly. ‘Next year,’ he said, ‘will be different.’ Stoudemire, the star of

  7. Blaine’s Stunt Sheds Light on Limits of Human Body

    ow Long Can You Hold Your Breath?

  8. Iraq Swears in 3 Key Security Ministers

    parliament approves and swears in 3 key security ministers to end impase

  9. GISFocus-Group Acquires KORDAB International AB

    Sweden, ESRI Finland, LandFocus and Meldis, is today’s leading provider of GIS solutions in Sweden and the acquisition

  10. Filtronic plans $83 million GaAs fab investment

    Powerwave is set to purchase the unit in a cash-and-stock deal valued at around $345 million.

  11. WNBA: Sky’s Dales Season Likely Over

    suffered the injury Wednesday in an 86-73 loss to the Seattle Storm. She experienced excruciating pain in the

  12. Venezuela, U.S. Reach Airline Agreement

    U.S. Reach Agreement to Avoid Proposed Airline Ban, U.S. Diplomat Says

  13. Glamour-Filled Finals Tip Off Thursday

    MOUNTAIN NEWS. Like the Super Bowl, like the World Series, like the Stanley Cup in a product placement sense, the NBA Finals are

  14. 22Moo VG-SD The World’s Most Affordable Video Glasses for the iPod Video

    Video Glasses for the iPod Video and other AV output enabled devices. (PRWEB Jun 15, 2006)

  15. Soldiers Describe ‘Emotional Roller Coaster’ Upon Return From War

    Toll on Battle-Hardened Vets Complicates Switch to Civilian Life

  16. Bush Trumpets Iraq Terror Leader’s Death

    Celebrates ‘Good Week’, With Terror Leader Al-Zarqawi Dead, Iraqi Government Complete