Book #24: Free Culture: The Nature and Future of Creativity, by Lawrence Lessig

Free Culture is an important book, well worth reading by anyone concerned by how digital media will affect free expression, inquiry, and culture. Although I came to Lessig after long use of, and involvement with, open source software, his arguments in favor of a cultural commons (what used to be called the “public domain”) should be compelling even without this background.

Lessig demostrates how the seemingly simple concept of a right to control copying of one’s work has been vastly extended in scope, and in the post-Internet world, threatens to erode more traditional concepts of “fair use” and the public domain. Most importantly, Lessig describes how this threat to traditional cultural freedom is fueled by an over-reaction among content owners over the possible effects of digital technologies to their current business models. The latter, I think, is the most important point – while traditionally our society has chosen to protect culture and leave the protection of business models to the operation of the market, in the war over copyright we’re allowing ourselves to protect business models to the detriment of culture.

And this is an issue where true free-market enthusiasts can make common cause with more traditional liberals. Current copyright law and legislation on digital media are protectionist of companies, not more fundamental economic rights. In other words, the MPAA and RIAA have succeeded in pushing protectionism for the pre-1995 business models of the content industries; furthermore, they’ve managed to go beyond protectionism and make digital copyright violations felonious in a way that older, “analog” violations usually were not.

True believers in free markets should abhor this kind of special-interest protectionism, and should welcome increased freedom for fair use and the public domain. These are, after all, the uncontrolled spaces in which innovation and unstructured competition can occur and thus for markets to periodically restructure themselves.

Traditional liberals, concerned about liberty and the threat that private media concentration creates for honest public debate, should welcome a vibrant and free public domain and ample “fair use” rights. These are, after all, the uncontrolled spaces in which dissent and social innovation can occur, and thus for social change to truly emerge out of deliberative and democratic efforts, rather than being focus-grouped, programmed, and stage-managed as is much of our current politics.

Naturally, radical free marketeers and traditional civil-rights liberals often have little common ground to discuss, and I’m not suggesting that this issue is the basis for a lasting alliance. But it is important to recognize those occasions when both groups could join together in opposition to fight government by lobbyist – a mode of political life that one imagines is causing James Madison to spin rapidly in his Montpelier tomb.

Comments

24 Comments so far. Comments are closed.
  1. Wounded Soldiers Fight Off Bill Collectors at Home

    Calls It ‘Financial Friendly Fire’; Military Blames Payroll Errors

  2. A Day Without Immigrants

    Without Immigrants” national demonstration day. I will not profess to have a silver bullet answer to immigration issues, but I encourage

  3. Parlano Announces Collaboration with Nokia to Provide MindAlign Mobile Client™

    messaging solutions, today announced an agreement with Nokia to license its Intellisync

  4. Mind the Baby Gap: Spacing Out Pregnancies Is Important

    Better to Wait a Few Years — but Not Too Many — Between Children, Study Shows

  5. Open: Rudy’s BIG bank

    but we really thought there was room for another one that we could build off the back of this brand.”

  6. Klinsmann springs surprise inclusion

    selection surprise by naming uncapped Borussia Dortmund striker David Odonkor in his squad for this summer’s

  7. Nelson’s Name Surfaces as Sacramento Replacement

    ever had,’ he said Tuesday afternoon. ‘I’m going to go about my business

  8. Entry-Level SAN Tool Bows

    enterprise resource analysis, monitoring and reporting tool for Windows and

  9. Howard’s Back Has Mavs Concerned

    Josh Howard grimaced through a particularly deep dig into the small of his back, writes Eddie Sefko of THE DALLAS MORNING NEWS. This

  10. Productivity, Wages Both Up

    last week, but the labor market appears in good shapes. And many merchants reported they had good Aprils.

  11. Pistons’ Hamilton Feeling Good

    campus Sunday, Richard Hamilton beamed. That’s because Hamilton pulled on a practice jersey and ran through an off-day workout for

  12. Vyew Enhances Free, Web 2.0 Online Conferencing with New VyewShow

    share custom photo slideshows set to MP3 tracks online (PRWEB Jun 1, 2006)

  13. Taxicab Concessions

    high-level wheeling and dealing makes all of us fare game (By Tom Robbins)

  14. China Pulls ‘Da Vinci Code’ Movie

    other motives. There is speculation that it may have been too popular, while

  15. Media Alert: Promise Phelon, CEO, The Phelon Group to Speak at Silicon Valley AMA?s First Annual Leadership Forum on Wednesday, June 14

    Phelon to discuss marketing leadership that leverages the voice of the customer. (PRWEB

  16. Exemestane for early breast cancer

    drug exemestane after two to three years of tamoxifen can improve survival

  17. Mavs Have a Lot on the Line in Game 4

    situations in the playoffs and haven’t panicked. They aren’t about to start now, writes Eddie Sefko of the DALLAS MORNING NEWS.

  18. Is Europe Complicit in Torture?

    charges that European countries are adopting a “see no evil, hear no evil” approach on helping the U.S. ship off terror suspects

  19. Murders More Prevalent in 2005, FBI Reports

    BC News Reviewed Crime Stats in Nation’s Most Populous Cities

  20. MIA/NJ Pre-Game Thoughts

    Conference Semi-Finals. As you know, in Game 1, the Nets just ran all over the Heat, tearing

  21. Wade and Payton Miss Heat’s Monday Workout

    Monday’s practice amid continued struggles with the flu. In addition, guard Gary Payton missed the workout at AmericanAirlines

  22. Silver Coin Dealers

    the US Shawnee Indian tribe and the US Poarch Creek Indian tribe, Silver and Our primary focus is da

  23. Mark,

    Well, it’s certainly the case that Hollywood tends to donate to Democrats, but the data on media ownership *in general* show a fairly broad spectrum, including heavy ownership by folks who identify as Republican. Murdoch’s News Corp, for example, is one of the five largest media companies in the world. The myth that media are “dominated” by liberals is simply false if you look at ownership data.

    Media are owned by *shareholders* in today’s world, some of whom are liberal, some of whom are conservative. All of whom are interested in making returns on their investments. Which means that regardless of ideological position, all media companies have a self-interest in pushing for copyright legislation which benefits large aggregators of content.

    The reality is that money flows from media companies on both sides of the aisle — Democrat and Republican — to political candidates, which causes both sides to support more restrictive copyright legislation. Lessig’s point is precisely this — neither party is willing to protect traditional rights of fair use or public domain because both parties recieve significant funding from media.

  24. Because all the media companies (movie studios, etc.) are dominated by liberals, and they donate money to Democratic candidaes, the Democrats protect them.