Is this the South rising again, or just folks who didn’t pay attention in history class? featured Christian Exodus today, a Texas non-profit planning to congregate 50,000+ Christian conservatives in one of three southern states and then secede from the United States. The plan is fascinating — committed members will select a state (Alabama, South Carolina, and Mississippi are candidates), move there into strategic legislative districts, and gain a majority to force a secession vote. The vote would be triggered by sheer numbers, or by an attempt to legalize same-sex marriage in their state of choice (or nationally).

It’s an interesting plan, but it’s not going to work. Secession doesn’t work like that. There is no procedure for secession in the Constitution, although there is no specific prohibition against it. Thus, precedent is likely to govern our reaction to future attempts at state secession. And the track record there isn’t good. Unilateral secession without national consent is precisely what triggered the Civil War — slavery was simply the issue that created the secessionist movement.

Following the war, the Supreme Court ruled in Texas v. White (74 U.S. 700) that ratification of the constitution and admission to statehood meant that the Union including Texas was an “indissoluble relation.” Chief Justice Salmon P. Chase, writing for the majority, went on to say that the only means of revocation is “through revolution or through consent of the States.”

Christian Exodus seems to be planning an entirely legalistic secession, but they’re ignoring the fact that even if secession were viewed favorably by outsiders, consent of Congress is required, according to Texas v. White. The law and precedent is thin here, but it seems unlikely that Congress would approve secession, and highly likely that a unilateral secession attempt would be dealt with as a rebellion against federal authority.

Not a good plan.


18 Comments so far. Comments are closed.
  1. Drew Sharp: Rasheed is Straw that Stirs Pistons

    writes that Rasheed Wallace is the composite Piston who incorporates all the attributes that evoke fear in the opposition.

  2. Heat’s Walker Now in Must-Stop Spot

    THE MIAMI HERALD writes, Walker, who replaced James Posey as a starter

  3. Clippers’ Mobley Making the Cut

    Stevens of the LOS ANGELES DAILY NEWS writes, While Elton Brand and Sam Cassell have established themselves as the Clippers’ go-to

  4. Chinese Party Elders Denounce Media Censorship

    closure of BingDian (Freezing Point), an investigative newspaper, along with the…

  5. David Moore: What Do Spurs Do Now?

    David Moore of THE DALLAS MORNING NEWS. It’s normally a huge mistake to attach too much significance to the outcome of the

  6. Bow Down to George Bush the Decider!

    verturning 750 laws since 2000 (By Mark Fiore)

  7. Mother’s Depressive Symptoms Contribute Unfavorably to Parenting Practices

    Depressive Symptoms Contribute Unfavorably to Parenting Practices

  8. Laborers’ Union To Break From AFL-CIO

    strategy to help its members win better pay and benefits and improved working conditions.

  9. Real-Life Princess Diaries: Prince Albert’s Second Love Child

    merican Teenage Girl Learns She’s Royalty

  10. Pistons Run Out of Game 6 Magic

    Boston. But it ended in Miami, with the Heat beating Detroit 95-78 in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference finals Friday –

  11. Mavs Going Deep in Hearts of Texans

    and played in a stadium with a hole in the roof so, as legend says, God could watch his favorite team.

  12. When locusts swarm en masse

    nsect critical density linked to group behaviour.

  13. Both sides rest in Polk case

    and are expected to give closing arguments on Monday. “The defense rests,” Polk

  14. New Author Beats Ann Coulter’s Book

    Cold Calling, on June 6th. The book reached the Amazon #1 bestseller spot in a

  15. Selling illegal immigrants the American dream

    as their 3-year-old son, Alexis, took out his toolbox and pretended to fix a closet in their new San Jose home.

  16. Ecuador vs Costa Rica Full-Time Score

    match-up reports, game previews, great free games with thousands in cash

  17. Bird Flu Death Toll in Indonesia at 38

    ests confirm girl’s death from bird flu, putting Indonesian toll at 38

  18. Wilbon: Dallas In Big Trouble In Finals

    did on Tuesday night. This is why you don’t let your concentration lapse because you think you’re cruising, up 2-0 in the series and